|
Post by George Willson on Oct 27, 2005 16:47:48 GMT -5
This is the oldest film I've ever seen. I've got D.W. Griffith's Birth of a Nation from 1915 lined up for the future as well as a variety of shorts Griffith did between 1908 and 1913, but so far this is the oldest.
This was a weird and interesting film. It involves a Dr. Caligari who has a somnambulist (someone who sleeps all the time) named Cesare that can tell your fortune. Meanwhile, while he's in town, murders are occurring. A man who lost his best friend to the murderer works to unravel the mystery of Caligari and Cesare before more deaths occur.
For a silent film, it was interesting to watch, and easy enough to follow. The intertitles, though long in nature, were done in an interesting to read font that fit with the character of the piece. The sets were really bizarre to look at as well (I believe this film was classified as German expressionism). It even had a decent twist at the end.
For some weak points, the characters were hardly delved into at all beyond their basic function in the story, and we weren't even told the name of the girl until near the end. Almost no relationships were established between the characters -- only a thin one between the main character and his best friend who was murdered -- so I believe that made the story a little thinner than it could have been.
For a film that was still falls under the experimental time of filmmaking, it managed to age very well over the years. Despite its weak points, we did get some change in the characters, and something good to watch.
|
|
Elliott
Tepish Fälskrüz
A movie's completed once the fat lady sings.
Posts: 18
|
Post by Elliott on Oct 28, 2005 14:30:37 GMT -5
How we can see character development in a silent film? Lol...
|
|
|
Post by George Willson on Oct 28, 2005 19:28:27 GMT -5
Pretty much the same way as a sound film. Metropolis is a good example of a silent film with great character development. Freder is an upper class guy who frolics in the garden. In a prince and pauper type move, Freder switches places with a worker. Through this he finds the underworld, and becomes a mediator between the upper and lower classes, something he could not have done without his experiences.
Freder's father is the head of the city. He does not associate with the lower classes, nor give them any notice. At the end fo the film he appears to want to do this, but is hesitant without the insistence of his son.
Some of this is accomplished through intertitles, but a lot is done through their actions. Film is a visual medium, and it's important to know where we came from in making it.
Consider the scenario of a man being shot. There are three ways to show this occurred in the story, each less good than the one before.
Best: Show the man being shot. Good: Show the man immediately after being shot. Last resort: The man says "I've been shot."
Silent films are forced to show everything, so they only have the first option, and they always found a way to do it. For a challenge, try making a silent film. Use scarce intertitles if you must, but try to tell a story using only visuals. For low budget, it is actually more doable than a normal film.
|
|
Elliott
Tepish Fälskrüz
A movie's completed once the fat lady sings.
Posts: 18
|
Post by Elliott on Oct 30, 2005 13:55:33 GMT -5
Oh, okay.
|
|